Why Is Australia Hosting a Leader Accused of Inciting Genocide?
Israeli President Isaac Herzog is scheduled to arrive in Australia on 8 February 2026 for a five-day visit following an official invitation from Prime Minister Anthony Albanese. The visit has sparked widespread condemnation from humanitarian organisations, legal experts, Labor MPs, Greens senators, and Palestinian advocacy groups. Central to the controversy are serious allegations that Herzog has incited genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, with both the International Court of Justice and a United Nations commission citing his statements as evidence of direct and public incitement to commit genocide.
The decision to host Herzog raises urgent questions about Australia’s commitment to international law, accountability for war crimes, and consistency in responding to human rights violations.
Herzog’s Alleged Incitement to Genocide
On 12 October 2023, Herzog made a statement that would become central to genocide allegations against Israeli leadership. Speaking to international media, Herzog declared: “It is an entire nation out there that is responsible… This rhetoric about civilians not aware, not involved – it’s absolutely not true”
These remarks were subsequently cited by South Africa in its landmark case before the International Court of Justice alleging that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. In January 2024, the ICJ issued provisional measures ordering Israel to take all steps to prevent genocide, prevent and punish incitement to genocide, and ensure the Israeli Defence Forces does not carry out genocidal acts.
In September 2025, a UN Commission of Inquiry concluded definitively that Herzog’s statements, along with those of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and then-Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, constituted “direct and public incitement to commit genocide” under Article III(c) of the 1948 Genocide Convention. The Commission found that Israeli authorities “have failed to take action against them to punish this incitement”.
In December 2024, Amnesty International released a comprehensive report determining that Israel “had been and is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza”. The organisation documented systematic patterns of killing, causing serious bodily and mental harm, deliberately inflicting conditions calculated to destroy Palestinians in whole or in part, and imposing measures intended to prevent births.
Australia’s Legal Obligations Under International Law
As a state party to both the Genocide Convention and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, Australia has explicit legal obligations to prevent and punish genocide and related offences, including incitement. These obligations do not disappear when a foreign head of state arrives as an official guest.
In January 2026, three legal organisations: the Australian Centre for International Justice, Palestinian human rights group Al-Haq, and the Al Mezan Center for Human Rights—formally requested that the Australian Federal Police investigate Herzog for his alleged role in war crimes and incitement to genocide. Their 10-page submission outlined “serious and credible criminal accusations of incitement to genocide and advocating genocide” attributed to Herzog during Israel’s military operations in Gaza that began on 7 October 2023.
Rawan Arraf, executive director of the Australian Centre for International Justice, stated: “Where credible international findings suggest incitement to genocide and domestic accountability has not been established, Australia possesses both the legal authority and the obligation to intervene”. She warned that allowing Herzog to enter Australia without an Australian Federal Police investigation would indicate “a blatant disregard” for Australia’s international legal commitments.
Amnesty International Australia echoed these concerns, stating that “allowing President Herzog to visit Australia as an official guest, without action on these widely held concerns, raises serious questions about Australia’s commitment to accountability and ending impunity for grave violations of human rights”.
Mounting Political Opposition Within Australia
The invitation to Herzog has prompted unprecedented dissent from within the Australian Labor Party itself, alongside vocal opposition from the Greens, independent MPs, and civil society. The Labor Friends of Palestine caucus, an internal faction, has repeatedly urged the government to withdraw the invitation.
Federal Labor MP Ed Husic, one of the few Muslim members of Parliament, has expressed being “uncomfortable” with Herzog’s visit, citing “images I’ve seen of him signing bombs that were subsequently dropped on Palestinian homes”. Husic referenced Herzog’s statements cited in the ICJ genocide case, noting these actions make it “difficult to reconcile” the visit.
Independent MP Sophie Scamps has joined calls to rescind the invitation, warning that the visit “risks igniting further division” in Australian society. Greens Senator David Shoebridge attempted to initiate a motion in the state Senate urging revocation of Herzog’s invitation, asserting that Herzog “has literally signed bombs used in the genocide in Gaza”.
NSW Labor backbenchers have also announced plans to protest Herzog’s visit in defiance of their own state premier, highlighting the depth of concern even among Labor’s ranks.
Human Rights Watch has called on Prime Minister Albanese to raise Israeli crimes with Herzog during his visit, noting that “it is impossible to ignore violations by the government Herzog represents”.
The Hypocrisy: Selective Accountability
Herzog’s visit highlights a troubling double standard in how Australia engages with different governments and leaders accused of human rights violations. While Australia imposes sanctions and travel bans on officials from some countries accused of atrocities, it rolls out the red carpet for others.
The decision to host Herzog sends a clear message: that accountability for genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity is selective, applied inconsistently based on political alliances rather than principles of international law and human rights.
As one Reddit user aptly summarised: “It’s comparable to a pro-Iranian group inviting Ayatollah Khamenei while the Federal and NSW Governments support it, even attempting to suppress protests”. The comparison illustrates the absurdity of hosting leaders credibly accused of grave violations simply because they represent allied states.
What Can We Do?
Australians who believe in consistent application of international law and accountability for all perpetrators of human rights violations can take action through several channels:
Sign Petitions
Jewish Council of Australia Petition: Jews across Australia have organised a petition titled “Jews say no to Israeli President Herzog” rejecting the narrative that Herzog’s visit represents the Australian Jewish community. The petition emphasises that many Australian Jews oppose the genocide in Gaza and reject Herzog speaking on their behalf.
Amnesty International Campaign: Amnesty Australia has launched a campaign calling on the Australian government to investigate Herzog for genocide and ensure Australia meets its obligations under the Genocide Convention.
Contact Your MPs
Write, call, or email your federal and state MPs expressing concern about Herzog’s visit and Australia’s failure to uphold its obligations under international law. Ask them to:
Publicly condemn Israel’s genocide in Gaza
Call for the Australian Federal Police to investigate Herzog’s alleged incitement to genocide
Support cutting military and intelligence ties with Israel
Advocate for sanctions and arms embargoes against Israel
Educate and Amplify Palestinian Voices
Share credible information from human rights organisations, UN bodies, and Palestinian journalists documenting the reality on the ground in Gaza. Counter misinformation and challenge narratives that justify or minimise genocide. Centre Palestinian voices and experiences in these conversations.
Demand Media Accountability
Contact Australian media outlets when coverage fails to accurately report on Gaza, uses dehumanising language about Palestinians, or uncritically platforms Israeli government narratives. Submit letters to the editor, lodge complaints with media regulators, and support independent media that provides honest coverage.
The Moral Stakes
The genocide in Gaza has claimed Tens of thousands Palestinian lives as of February 2026, with the majority being women and children. Entire families have been erased. Hospitals, schools, universities, mosques, churches, and refugee camps have been deliberately destroyed. Starvation is being used as a weapon of war. The international legal architecture established after the Holocaust to prevent such atrocities is being tested, and Australia’s response will be remembered.
As Holocaust survivor and pro-Palestine activist Steven Kaplan wrote: “We, the Jewish survivors of immense suffering, oppose the Israeli government’s exploitation of Holocaust memory as a justification for the ongoing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank”.
Australia must choose: Will it stand consistently for human rights, international law, and accountability? Or will it selectively apply these principles based on political convenience, undermining the very foundations of the rules-based international order it claims to uphold?
The Palestinian people deserve justice. The Australian people deserve leaders who uphold international law without exception. And future generations deserve a world where genocide is prevented and punished, regardless of who commits it.
